Welcome!

"In many ways, the work of a critic is easy. We risk very little yet enjoy a position over those who offer up their work and their selves to our judgment. We thrive on negative criticism, which is fun to write and to read. But the bitter truth we critics must face, is that in the grand scheme of things, the average piece of junk is probably more meaningful than our criticism designating it so. But there are times when a critic truly risks something, and that is in the discovery and defense of the new."
-Anton Ego, Ratatouille

With aspirations to become an arts/entertainment reporter or critic, I have started this website to post weekly reviews of the latest cinematic offerings from Hollywood and around the world. Currently studying Film and Journalism at Carleton University in Ottawa, Ontario, I hope my reviews here are the start to a long and fulfilling road down the path of reporting.

Friday, September 11, 2009

Revolution "9"

Movie: 9

Rating: **1/2 out of ****

Directed by: Shane Acker

Featuring the voice talents of: Elijah Wood, John C. Reilly, Jennifer Connelly, Christopher Plummer, Martin Landau

Running Time: 79 minutes

Like the doll-like creations that populate 9, animator Shane Acker’s directorial debut, the film is spectacularly and imaginatively designed, but also feels incomplete and emotionally stagnant.

Expanded from Acker’s Oscar-nominated animated short, 9 is a bold and amibitious first feature.

It’s set in a dismal and decimated industrial landscape, after mankind has been demolished by hyperactive machines. The only inhabitants left in this wasteland are “stitchpunks,” tiny rag dolls with metallic hands, bodies patched up with cloth, binocular eyes and numbers emblazoned on their backs.

One of these stitchpunks, #9 (voiced by Elijah Wood), wakes up in a laboratory one dreary morning to find that it’s the end of the world as he knows it. And he doesn’t feel too fine, walking out into a dim, barren ghetto, needing to hide from the mechanical menaces who swarm the skies.

On this day, #9 meets a kind and elderly scientist stitchpunk, #2 (Martin Landau). When this new companion is attacked by a beastly machine and then carried off to a looming industrial tower in the distance, #9 sets off to rescue his friend.

However, #9’s early efforts to save #2 only awaken mechanical beasts whom are even more treacherous. And thus, he teams up with a troupe of stitchpunks to destroy the perilous machines.

They include: #1 (Christopher Plummer), the shady and domineering leader; #5 (John C. Reilly), the trustworthy and highly-intelligent engineer, #6 (Crispin Glover), a heavily troubled artist, and #7 (Jennifer Connelly), the reckless and physically robust warrior.

Technically, 9 is a bona-fide masterpiece. Acker is an assured animator who has created some fascinating visuals. The hazy backgrounds have the haunting, oozing qualities of a Dali painting, and the film’s numerous creatures are stitched with meticulous detail. The monsters in this film have such imaginative structure and movement, we can only wish that Acker dethrones Michael Bay as the director of future Transformers movies.

9 also zips along at a breakneck pace, ensuring that many of the action sequences are downright thrilling.

However, at only one and a quarter hours, there’s too much frantic violence and not enough character development. There is a time for action and mayhem and a time to break from the action and mayhem and enhance our interest in the story and characters. 9 unfortunately leaves these latter moments aside.

There is, however, one cheerful scene where many of the stitchpunks find a record player, put on the classic “Over the Rainbow,” and get a chance to dance, frolick and interact with each other. It is a beautiful moment and much needed change of pace for the characters; unfortunately, the film then goes right back into nonstop violence.

Furthermore, the stitchpunks have little personality or emotional depth. They refuse to branch off from their generic archetypes to become fresh, unique characters. If only the animation had sacrificed a few of its dimensions and given it to this slew of stitchpunks.

And while 9 is far too intense for younger audiences, the film’s rudimentary dialogue is geared toward schoolchilden. The lines, at certain points, seem to have been mechanically programmed for these characters.

Acker’s vision is unique, but 9’s environment is an all-too-familiar one. The film’s flashback scenes depicting war between humans and hyperactive technology instantly bring Terminator’s Judgement Day to mind. As well, the murderous machines, originally built to assist humans but whom have ultimately become a tamperance, recall 2001: A Space Odyssey and even Wall-E.

If 9 will be remembered for anything, it’ll be as a sharply crafted debut from a young visionary. While its technical aspects are stunningly complex and entirely dazzling, the story elements and characters remain too generic to ensure that the film can be remembered as anything more.

2 comments:

  1. Great review. I was thinking of taking my younger granddaughters to see this film, but after reading your review, I will not venture to this violent film.
    Keep up the great writing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the great review. Gave enough detail and insight without giving it all away. I was thinking of watching 9 with my 10 yr old son, but will now wait until he's asleep.

    Love the REM line - subtle, and effective to anyone who catches it.

    Any idea how the studios pick the actors to use as voice overs? Interesting how they used Christopher Plummer and Martin Landau - 2 true legends. Glad to see they are still relevant.

    I really disliked Wall E, especially the scenes with the "classic" film (that nobody even knows what it is) that he replayed over and over. Thrilled to see that Wizard of Oz had an impact on such a soon to be prolific director.

    And yes, I will be petitioning to get Wizard of OZ on your top 10 list on every comment, or at least have you consider having a top 11 list so that you don't have to remove any of your favourites.

    ReplyDelete